Should you scan photos yourself or use a scanning service?
Use a service when the prints are loose, you would rather pay than spend your evenings, and you can be without them for several weeks. Scan them yourself when they are stuck in albums, when you would rather not mail them, or when you want to pick out the ones worth keeping as you go.
How much does it cost to digitize 1,000 photos?
Here is what each mail-in service’s own page says, with the day we checked it, next to the two ways of doing it yourself.
| Option | Price | What it takes | Your time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legacybox, mail-in | $79.99 for 1,000 photos, 8¢ per photo, in the 4x6 Photo Legacybox for 3x5 and 4x6 prints, returned as 72 dpi JPEGs with a free 30-day Legacybox Membership, then $7.99 every 30 days until canceled (checked ) | Loose prints only, no albums or sticky prints; JPEG files through a membership that renews after its free period unless you cancel; originals back | Packing, then several weeks without the prints |
| ScanMyPhotos, mail-in | 20¢ per scan at 300 dpi or 50¢ per scan at 600 dpi, with a $25 minimum that does not include return shipping; the download link costs $5.95 for 5 days up to $29.95 for 1 year (checked ) | Loose prints only, no albums; you choose the resolution; the download link and return shipping cost extra | Packing, then several weeks without the prints |
| HeritageBox, mail-in | $599 for the Lifetime Archive box, up to 40 tapes, reels or 1,000 photos (checked ) | Prints, negatives, slides, tapes and film reels in one box; files on USB or in the cloud | Packing, then several weeks without the prints |
| Flatbed scanner at home | The scanner, if you do not own one | Any print that lies flat; files at the resolution you choose | The most: you place, scan and crop every pass |
| iPhone app at home | From free to a one-time price or a membership, listed below | Loose prints and album pages as they are | Less than a scanner: one shot per print, or per page with an app that finds several photos |
Each service counts differently: per photo, per kit of one print size, or per box shared with tapes and reels. So compare what you would actually send, and read the whole price: the files from Legacybox come through a membership that renews after its free period, and ScanMyPhotos charges for the download link and the return shipping on top of each scan. Check the resolution too, because it decides how large you can print a photo later.
Scanning apps, as their App Store pages list them:
- PhotoScan by Google Photos: Free (checked )
- Pic Scanner Gold: $9.99, a “One-time purchase for unlimited, lifetime use” (checked )
- Photo Scan App by Photomyne: Free, with memberships “available as monthly, yearly, and one-time plans”; in-app purchases: Photomyne account $9.99, $35.99, $6.99, $29.99; Photomyne membership $59.99, $14.99, $19.99; Photomyne account (yearly) $59.99; Restore photo credits $3.99 (checked )
- Photo Scan Plus by Photomyne: $1.99, “the paid one-time purchase version of Photomyne”; in-app purchases: Photomyne account $39.99, $9.99, $17.99, $1.99, $47.99, $19.99; Photomyne membership $59.99, $19.99, $29.99 (checked )
What each app does well is in how to scan photos with an iPhone, and the Photomyne plans are explained in our Photomyne review.
What does doing it yourself really cost?
Mostly time. On a flatbed scanner, three 4×6 prints fit on a letter-size glass at once, so 1,000 prints means more than 330 passes, and each pass has to be split into separate photos, by the scanner’s software or by hand. With an iPhone it is one shot per print, or one shot per album page with an app that finds several photos in one frame, and the prints never leave the house.
The quality differs too. A flatbed scanner gives the most faithful copy; a careful phone photo is good enough to share and to print again at the original size.
When is a service the better choice?
- The prints are loose, in shoeboxes or envelopes, not glued into albums.
- You have more money than time, and you can wait several weeks for the files.
- You have tapes and film reels too. HeritageBox takes them in the same box as photos, and Legacybox has a mixed box for tapes, reels, audio and slides.
When is scanning at home the better choice?
- The photos are in albums, especially the old sticky ones. Legacybox’s bulk photo box and ScanMyPhotos both say they do not scan albums, and prying prints off a sticky page can tear them.
- You would rather not mail them. A box in the mail can be lost, however careful the service is.
- You want to sort as you go, and write down who is in each photo while the person who knows is sitting next to you.
- You have a few negatives or slides. See how to convert slides to digital and how to scan negatives with an iPhone.
Can Walgreens turn photos into digital?
Yes. Walgreens Photo’s Home Movie & Print Digitization page says photo prints, negatives and slides can be transferred to a USB drive, and that everything is returned once the transfer is done (checked November 15, 2026). Ask at the photo counter what your batch would cost and how long it will be away before you hand it over.
What are we building?
For the albums that should not go in the mail, we are building an app that will scan a whole album page in one shot, crop each photo and keep everything on the iPhone, as a one-time purchase with the first photos free and no subscription. It is Fotomory, our iPhone app – not on the App Store yet.
Step by step
- 1
Count and sort the prints
Count roughly how many prints you have, set aside duplicates and blurry shots, and note which are loose and which are in albums.
- 2
Choose the route for each pile
Send loose prints to a service if you would rather pay than spend the evenings. Keep albums, stuck prints and the ones you could never replace for scanning at home.
- 3
Photograph the irreplaceable prints before you mail anything
A quick iPhone photo of each print you could not replace is a copy you still have if a box is lost in the mail.
- 4
Keep two copies of the files
As soon as the scans arrive, save them on your computer and in one more place, such as a cloud service or an external drive.
Scan the whole page at once
Photograph an album page once and you will get every photo on it cut out, with who, when and where kept alongside. That will be the job of Fotomory, our iPhone app – not on the App Store yet.